HostGator and Hostinger both started out as independent hosts, but HostGator was bought out by Endurance International Group (EIG) almost a decade ago. Does this big-brand backing and the infrastructure that goes with it give HostGator the edge? Well, not necessarily.
To find out which of these two web hosts is better, I ran some extensive tests on both of them. I checked their performance, features, and security, compared their pricing, and even contacted customer support to see which host provides better service.
There’s no doubt about it – in this comparison, Hostinger is the clear winner. It provides excellent performance at prices that just can’t be beat. Click here to see Hostinger’s latest deals, or read on for all the details.
Hostinger’s Cheap Plans Are Tough for HostGator to Beat
For shared hosting, Hostinger has three low-priced plans. Monthly, you’ll pay pocket change for hosting a site here. The Single plan lets you host one website, while Premium and Business provide additional features and functionality.
The top plan, Business, includes 200 GB of SSD storage, unlimited bandwidth allowance, and unlimited databases. You’ll also get a free domain, free SSL, and free daily backups. Unless you are on an extremely tight budget, this plan is my recommended pick for a good balance of features and pricing.HostGator is also known for low pricing, but its plans are slightly more expensive than Hostinger’s. HostGator has three shared hosting plans – Hatchling, Baby, and Business – and each offers unmetered bandwidth and storage. That said, HostGator only provides HDD storage. These drives run more slowly than the SSD drives provided with Hostinger.
It’s also worth noting that HostGator offers a free domain name for a year with every plan. Hostinger offers one with every plan besides Single Shared Hosting. If you’re looking for a more advanced hosting solution, both hosts also offer VPS for reasonable prices.While HostGator’s unlimited resources are certainly a nice bonus, you need to ask yourself: would you really need them? Hostinger’s shared hosting plans already offer plenty of space and bandwidth to work with for a lower price, along with a much faster SSD storage solution. It’s a tight contest, but I’d say Hostinger would be the better value option for most.
Hostinger Offers a More User-Friendly Control Panel
If you’re new to hosting, you might be looking for one-click WordPress installers and website builders. Both HostGator and Hostinger will meet your requirements there.
But here’s a big difference. HostGator uses cPanel, and Hostinger doesn’t. This might matter if you want something more advanced from your hosting plan.
cPanel is a web hosting control panel that lets you look after the technical side of your hosting account yourself. Through cPanel, HostGator has support for practically every programming language and feature you could dream of. CGI, Ruby, and Python right down to instant installers for forums and guestbooks. If you’re used to cPanel, the learning curve after you move hosts will be non-existent, and its Business plan is ready for e-commerce out of the box.
Hostinger has a custom panel called hPanel, which always requires a little more getting used to when you move from another host. However, when my colleague tested Hostinger’s control panel, he found it very easy to use. cPanel does offer access to more features, but most of us won’t be using most of them, so it can feel a little cluttered.
Here’s a side-by-side comparison of the features offered by both hosts:
In general, Hostinger’s features are great for beginners – the plans provide everything you need. There are also a few extra perks, such as the WP Starter wizard, an AI which helps you build the framework for your site. After asking you a few questions, it will help you select an appropriate theme and install necessary plugins, giving you a nice head start on site development.
Shared hosting slices a server into individual accounts; they’re separate, but share the same underlying server resources between them. There are sometimes performance problems on shared hosting when one site starts to consume resources that its neighbors need.
There’s no way of guarding against this, but HostGator does refer to “low-density servers” on WordPress plans. I’m inferring that it means it limits the number of customers per server, and if so, that should help with your site’s speed and performance. Unfortunately, there’s no real detail to go on.
HostGator says it loads pages “up to 2x faster” thanks to “premium hardware” and caching. In truth, the plugins you run on your own website are likely to impact performance more dramatically than the server hardware, but again — let’s go with the positives here.
Hostinger also offers plenty of tools to help boost performance, such as LiteSpeed web servers and the associated LSCache optimization plugin. Both give Hostinger a definite edge, and that’s not even mentioning its SSD storage, which outperforms HostGator’s older HDD drives.
Both hosts’ uptime guarantees are very similar, with cloud hosting providing marginally better uptime promises than other types of hosting.
All in all, Hostinger offers better hardware and software – and it goes to great lengths to ensure its servers are optimized. That’s why it’s the clear winner of this section.
Hostinger is the fastest shared hosting service we’ve tested, and its uptime score was almost perfect. For the full test results, see our in-depth Hostinger review.
HostGator’s performance isn’t bad, although some users have complained about slow speeds and a bit of downtime. Read our full HostGator review to find out what went wrong.
Both Hostinger and HostGator offer a free security suite to keep your sites and data safe. Each host includes a custom firewall, DDoS protection, and SSL certificates with every plan. These security measures are average for the shared hosting industry – it’d work fine for a basic low-traffic site, but for mission-critical projects you may wish to tighten up security further with third-party solutions. HostGator offers SiteLock for an ongoing fee, which provides automatic malware scans and protection against bot attacks.It’s worth noting that Hostinger experienced a data breach in the past that exposed hashed passwords and the personal data of over 14 million customers. HostGator, despite being in the industry for a similar amount of time, has never experienced a major breach. While Hostinger has since improved security significantly, HostGator has proven to be reliable and secure throughout all its years doing business. For that reason, HostGator is the winner of this section.
HostGator Provides Great Support in Minutes – Hostinger Leaves You Waiting for Hours
Hostinger and HostGator both offer 24/7 support via live chat, email, and tickets. However, HostGator also offers 24/7 phone support if you prefer. Both hosts also offer extensive knowledge bases filled with tutorials and guides on the basics of web hosting.I personally tested the quality of support offered by each host by asking some basic questions. First, I tried to get in touch with HostGator’s live chat support. However, HostGator left me waiting for over ten minutes. That isn’t a horrendous waiting time, but it wouldn’t be very good if I’d had a critical issue that needed immediate attention.That said, HostGator replied much more promptly than Hostinger. Upon trying to get in touch via live chat, Hostinger informed me that the average response time is “a few hours.”You can close the chat window at any time and still receive a response to your queries by email. But of course, that isn’t really live chat anymore. To actually connect and chat with an agent, it seems you’re forced to contact them outside peak hours – and even then, it’ll take some luck.Thankfully, the actual support offered by both hosts was great – the agents politely cleared up my questions and gave me all the information I was looking for.All in all, HostGator gives you access to quality support in a fraction of the time it takes with Hostinger – even though it isn’t particularly quick either.
While HostGator has a better security record and faster support response times, it wasn’t enough to beat Hostinger’s superior performance and overall value.Hostinger made our list of the top ten hosting providers in 2023 for a reason – it’s one of your best options. Unfortunately, it’s more difficult to recommend HostGator. Here’s a side-by-side comparison of Hostinger and HostGator to make the differences clear.
Plans and Pricing
Low prices with generous resources and fast SSD
Low prices with unlimited resources, but outdated & slow HDD
Beginner-friendly proprietary control panel; WP Starter wizard helps you create your first site
Includes the popular cPanel, with plenty of tools for developers
Superior performance and great uptime in our tests
Slow performance and some downtime in our tests
Satisfactory security suite
Decent security included & additional premium options
Hostinger offers great value for money, but such a huge number of customers means you may have to wait a few hours for a response from support during peak periods. In addition, Hostinger offers a proprietary control panel that non-techies might find easier to use, but more experienced users may prefer to pay more for the more familiar cPanel. Web hosting companies are charged licensing fees to offer cPanel to their customers, and this can drive up the price of hosting plans.
Is Hostinger better than Bluehost?
Yes. Hostinger delivers better performance at a lower price, so there’s little reason to choose Bluehost. Hostinger also made our list of the top web hosts in 2023, while Bluehost didn’t even come close.
Claire Broadley has been reviewing and comparing web hosting companies for more than 10 years. She’s a tech enthusiast and trained technical author, and writes about everything from EVs to the history of the internet. Claire lives in the UK with her husband, two kids, and two pugs.