Hootsuite vs Buffer – Dare to Guess a Winner? [UPDATED 2019]

Hootsuite vs Buffer – Dare to Guess a Winner? [UPDATED 2019]

Sharon Hurley Hall
Sharon Hurley Hall
40

If you’re a blogger, digital marketer, or social media manager looking to up your game, at some point you’ll want to think about saving time and effort by scheduling your social media content in advance. You’ll also want insights and analytics that can help you improve your reach.

The only trouble is, there are a bunch of tools out there, and it’s hard to know which one has the right features for your particular situation.

Two of the most recommended social media management tools are Hootsuite and Buffer. But how do you know which one is better for personal bloggers, and which one works best for digital marketing teams?

We’ve done the hard work for you, pitting Hootsuite against Buffer in a range of categories, including:

  • Supported social networks
  • Integrated external services
  • User interface and ease of use
  • Publishing, scheduling, and importing content
  • Social conversations
  • Depth of analytics
  • Team features

We looked at what’s available in each tool for free, as well as some of the pro features, to give you a reliable guide to what will work best in your situation.

By the end of our comparison, you’ll have the information you need to make your own mind up, and decide whether Hootsuite or Buffer wins for you.

Buffer Supports Five Social Networks – Hootsuite Supports Even More

A social media scheduling tool is useless if it doesn’t support the social networks you need.

Buffer supports Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, Instagram and Pinterest, although you can’t use Pinterest in the free version.

Hootsuite vs. Buffer - Dare To Guess a Winner [2019 UPDATED]-image1

With Buffer, you can add both Facebook pages and groups, as well as LinkedIn profiles and pages. Depending on your plan, you can add multiple profiles for each platform.

You have more options with Hootsuite. In addition to Twitter, Facebook (profiles, pages, and groups), LinkedIn (profiles and pages), Instagram, and Pinterest, Hootsuite also allows you to schedule content for WordPress blogs and YouTube channels.

Hootsuite vs. Buffer - Dare To Guess a Winner [2019 UPDATED]-image2

And the Winner Is…

Hootsuite has the edge in terms of the number of platforms it supports. And if you’re also looking to schedule video and blog content, then it’s really the perfect choice. But if you’re only using the standard platforms, other Buffer features might make it the better option for you.

Hootsuite Supports 140+ Integrations – Buffer Has Fewer

If you’re a digital marketer using multiple tools, then you’ll want to make your life easier by bringing everything under one roof. Hootsuite makes this easy, with more than 140 integrations available via its App Directory. It’s got apps for marketing automation, managing ads, influencer marketing, and other common digital marketing functions.

In contrast, Buffer’s list of integrations is a lot more modest (around 65). Bloggers will find its Feedly and Pocket integrations useful as they let you share content to Buffer with a single click.

And the Winner Is…

By the numbers, it looks like Hootsuite’s the winner – but not so fast! Both have Zapier integrations, which levels the playing field. That’s because Zapier connects applications to each other to give a wide range of functions, like automatically importing and scheduling content, even from sites that aren’t natively supported. That makes it a tie in our book.

Buffer Has a Modern Interface – Hootsuite Needs a Refresh

Do looks matter in a social media scheduling tool? We think they do, because if you’re staring at your screen for much of the day, you want it to be easy on the eyes.

Seriously, though, Buffer has a clean, modern interface, where it’s easy to add and manage social media accounts. You can also quickly add new content to your Buffer queue, see what’s already scheduled, and check out analytics.

Hootsuite vs. Buffer - Dare To Guess a Winner [2019 UPDATED]-image3

Hootsuite’s dashboard looks clunky and cluttered next to Buffer’s. Of course, Hootsuite isn’t JUST a social media scheduling tool. The dashboard includes widgets for keeping tabs on social media streams, as well as posting tools (we’ll look at those a bit later), so it’s no wonder things can get a bit unwieldy.

Hootsuite vs. Buffer - Dare To Guess a Winner [2019 UPDATED]-image4

And the Winner Is…

Buffer, by a mile. Hootsuite is powerful, but Buffer’s simplicity is hard to beat.

Buffer Rocks For Publishing and Scheduling – Hootsuite Has Other Advantages

Once your Buffer account is set up, publishing can be as simple as clicking on the calendar date you want, typing in your post, and pressing Add to Queue to include it in your publishing schedule.

With Buffer, everything you need is in one handy place, making it easy to:

  • Add emojis to your social media post
  • Upload images
  • Share the same post to multiple networks
  • Decide whether you want to share content immediately, add it to your queue, or schedule it

Hootsuite vs. Buffer - Dare To Guess a Winner [2019 UPDATED]-image5

It feels intuitive and easy. Buffer also includes the Pablo image creation tool, which is great for quickly developing and sharing visual content that looks professional.

With Hootsuite, the process is slightly different. If you’re in the Planner view, you can click on a date to bring up the post creation function. Otherwise, press the New Post button in the Publisher view, and it brings up a window where you can:

  • Select your social network
  • Add emojis
  • Upload images
  • Select social networks

Hootsuite vs. Buffer - Dare To Guess a Winner [2019 UPDATED]-image6

 

Hootsuite is better than Buffer at showing an immediate post preview, which is a timesaver. You press a different button depending on whether you want to post content immediately or schedule it for later. Hootsuite also has a handy Save Draft function (only available in Buffer Business or Pro plans).

You can see scheduled content in the Buffer dashboard, a month at a time, which is handy, and you can also switch to a weekly or a list view. Hootsuite’s Planner only shows you a week at a time. However, Hootsuite does have an auto-scheduling feature that some will find useful.

It’s worth noting that both Buffer and Hootsuite have browser extensions to let you share or queue content on the fly from any browser. With Buffer’s tool, you can also easily share any image you find on the web. Buffer’s also integrated into a bunch of other social media sharing tools and plugins.

However, there’s a big difference in the number of social posts you can pre-schedule with each platform, and that might be a deal breaker for a busy marketer or blogger.

Hootsuite’s free plan lets you schedule 30 posts, compared with just ten on Buffer. When you upgrade, you get unlimited posts with Hootsuite, while Buffer still imposes caps.

And the Winner Is…

It’s a tie. Buffer edges Hootsuite out because of its compact interface, ease of use, and its image creation tool. Scheduling is what Buffer excels at, while Hootsuite has a whole range of other functions. But if you’re looking to plan your social media content well ahead, Hootsuite’s unlimited scheduled posts is an attractive feature of its paid plans.

RSS Import: Hootsuite Offers It Free, but Has Limitations

An important feature for both bloggers and digital marketers is being able to import content from RSS feeds.

This allows you to both get content from your own blog for easy scheduling, as well as to import content from the blogs you follow so you can share the best content with your networks. Both Buffer and Hootsuite have this feature, although it’s a paid feature with Buffer.

As always, Buffer makes it easy to find, as it’s prominent on the one-page dashboard. Once you add the RSS URL, Buffer shows you the latest content almost instantly.

Hootsuite vs. Buffer - Dare To Guess a Winner [2019 UPDATED]-image7

 

With Hootsuite, you’ll need to navigate to the Content tool and go to RSS feeds. But adding a feed is more complex, as you also have to choose a default social account to post to when you do. Sure, this is useful, but do you really need to decide this now? Plus, changes to APIs for Twitter and Facebook mean that this feature no longer works for those platforms.

Hootsuite vs. Buffer - Dare To Guess a Winner [2019 UPDATED]-image8

Both tools will show you recent content for the feeds you follow, and allow you to schedule this content quickly and easily. In our trial, however, when trying to schedule with Hootsuite, it asked us to authenticate our Twitter account again, which seemed like an unnecessary step.

And the Winner Is…

Hard to say, so we’ll call it a tie. Since this function is available for free, Hootsuite looks like the winner, though its functionality is limited. But if you’re paying for Buffer, its version is slicker and easier, with no unnecessary complications.

Social Conversations: Hootsuite Has You Covered

Social media is about being social, so it’s handy to be able to respond to social media messages in the same platform where you’re scheduling content.

Hootsuite makes this simple with its Streams feature. With this, you can interact with social media just the same as on the native interface, which is pretty cool.

Unfortunately, you won’t get this with Buffer unless you spring for a Buffer Reply subscription, which can be pretty costly.

And the Winner Is...

Hootsuite, easily, since Buffer Publish doesn’t include it.

Buffer Offers Basic Analytics on Posts; Hootsuite’s Got Even More

Whether you’re a marketer or a blogger, you’ll want to know how your content is performing. Both platforms will help you to do that, but one’s got something extra.

Buffer provides some analytics on content, and you can see this for each post in the Analytics tab. However, the analytics function in both the free and Pro plans is very basic. If you want in-depth analytics, you’ll have to upgrade to a Buffer Premium plan or higher, or take a pricey Buffer Analyze subscription.

Need some extra guidance? Here’s how to use Buffer analytics to improve your social media strategy.

Hootsuite vs. Buffer - Dare To Guess a Winner [2019 UPDATED]-image9

In contrast, once you’ve added your social media accounts, Hootsuite will analyze ALL of your social content, whether posted through the platform or not. This is a useful feature for social media managers, especially as you can create and send reports on social media performance.

However, you’ll need to upgrade to a team plan to create custom analysis reports that pulls from more than 200 metrics.

And the Winner Is…

Hootsuite, for offering analytics around your entire social media networks, not just the individual posts that you’ve scheduled through the tool.

Hootsuite Has More Team Features Than Buffer

For digital marketers or social media managers, it’s useful to be able to hand off some of your social media tasks to colleagues. Both Buffer and Hootsuite have plans that work well for teams.

For less than $100 a month, Hootsuite’s team plan gives you:

  • 3 users
  • 20 social profiles
  • Unlimited scheduling
  • Team messaging and assignments
  • Custom analytics

For the same price, Buffer’s small business plan offers:

  • 6 users
  • 25 social profiles
  • 2,000 scheduled messages (per social account)
  • Advanced social analytics

If you want a team social inbox, you’ll need to subscribe to the costly Buffer Reply service.

And the Winner Is…

It’s a tie. If your team is three people or less, you can’t beat the unlimited scheduling and team messaging features that Hootsuite offers. However, for a bigger team, Buffer is clearly more cost-effective, and who really needs more than 2,000 scheduled messages anyway?

So, Which Social Media Tool Takes the Crown?

After comparing Hootsuite against Buffer, the winner was clear. As a longtime Buffer user and fan, I confidently expected Buffer to win, but the evidence says that Hootsuite takes the crown.

Here’s a summary of the key results:

FeatureConclusion
Supported social networksHootsuite supports way more social networks than the five Buffer supports
External integrationsHootsuite has double the number of integrations of Buffer, but since both work with Zapier, it’s a tie
User interfaceBuffer’s interface is cleaner and simpler than Hootsuite’s
Publishing and schedulingBuffer is primarily a publishing and scheduling tool, and does it better than Hootsuite – but Hootsuite has a wider range of features
RSS importHootsuite is great because this feature is available in its free plan, but Buffer’s paid feature is much more intuitive
Social conversationsHootsuite wins because conversations are part of a separate paid Buffer tool
AnalyticsHootsuite wins because it’s got analytics for ALL your social content, not just content posted via the platform
Team featuresHootsuite has a greater range of features for smaller teams, but for larger teams, Buffer is the better choice

But which one is the right one for you?

If you’re just posting content on the big five social networks and want a clean and simple interface, Buffer is a great choice. But if your social network is wider and you want an all-in-one social media dashboard, then Hootsuite is the only option.

Check out our in-depth Buffer and Hootsuite reviews for even more insight.

40 claps
Clap for the post if you found it useful!

Any comments?

0 out of minimum 100 characters
Required Field Maximal length of comment is equal 80000 chars Minimal length of comment is equal 100 chars

Get just one email a month and take your skills to the next level.

Sign up Now!

We check all user comments within 48 hours to make sure they are from real people like you. We're glad you found this article useful - we would appreciate it if you let more people know about it.

Share this blog post with friends and co-workers right now:

We check all comments within 48 hours to make sure they're from real users like you. In the meantime, you can share your comment with others to let more people know what you think.

Once a month you will receive interesting, insightful tips, tricks, and advice to improve your website performance and reach your digital marketing goals!

© 2019 WebsitePlanet.com. All Rights Reserved.